Weekly WIN: truculent


One Step Now Education

March 7, 2025

truculent

In Tim Alberta's book, "The Kingdom, The Power, and The Glory," he writes about a “raving truculent mess of a cattle call.” I'm familiar with the word truculent, but it's one of those familiar words that I'm not really sure what it means.

Due to its pronunciation, I get curious about any similarities to truck. Surely there's not a relationship there? Join me as we discover how the pronunciation of a word might lead you astray.


Meaning

What is this word's meaning and how does the word function?

What exactly is meant by a "raving truculent mess of a cattle call?"

First, I would need to process "a cattle call," an idiom used to describe an audition or application process where hundreds of applicants might be seen at once. I found this great site, CrossIdiomas, which is a great resource to find the history of such phrases. As our students get older, more idioms and figurative language show up, even in the informational text they are reading. Many of our students who were formerly successful with literal understanding of the text they're reading may hit a wall when it comes to the figurative language.

I can easily picture a "cattle call" with tons of people showing up. I can even close my eyes and see the "mess" it might be. However, what about this adjective, truculent? I know it is an adjective because it is modifying the noun mess.

When we look at the Collins dictionary entry, we see that someone who is truculent is "bad-tempered" and "aggressive." We can see how many people in this state can devolve into a mess.

Structure

What are the elements that make up this word's structure?

I'm making sense of the structure of this word now. Sometimes the meaning can help me understand the structure, but the structure can also help me with the meaning. Although we lay out these four questions in a linear manner to process, their influence on the word's orthography is more recursive.

The suffix <-ent> is often found on bases when an adjectival form is needed. We can see this on words like persistent or different. This isn't always the case, however, as we see with student or president.

trucul + ent

I'm seeing another possibility here. I know two other potential suffixes that might be present here: <-ule> and <-cule>.

truc + ule/ + ent
tru + cule/ + ent

That slash mark is to indicate that I'll need to replace that truculent.

In fact, I would also need to do that with the base in my first hypothesis as well:

truce/ + ule/ + ent

The pattern of a single vowel by a single consonant in the base would prompt doubling

*trucculent

Since this is not the case, I must assume the base contains an

But in both hypotheses, I'm wondering, is the word related to true, truth, and truce? It certainly doesn't seem to have a connection to truck.

Let's look at the entry in Etymonline to guide us with the root of this word. Knowing the root of a word can help us determine its base in Modern English. Words like fierce and savage greet us right away. These are great synonyms to consider when working on the first question. It appears our root is from Latin trux, where it means the same. Then Douglas, the creator of Etymonline, gives us the genitive form of this Latin adjective. The genitive form is what we will need to determine our English base.

When going from a Latin noun or adjective to an English base, we remove the genitive suffix, &amp;amp;amp;lt;-is&amp;amp;amp;gt; from trucis, and there we arrive at

Relatives

What are the word's relatives and history?

Then, is there a relationship with truck or truce? Well, according to Etymonline, the word truck is from a Greek word via Latin, trokhos, "wheel." No luck there.

A relationship to truce seems more likely, eh? But our steam runs out here too. The word truce, related to true and truthcomes from the Old English treow, "faith; pledge; promise."

So are there any relatives for the base truculent? Well of course there's the noun form, truculence. There is an adverb form as well, truculently.

In Latin, this word had a verbal form, trucidare, which may be the source of the English trucidation, a "cruel murder."

The phrase "leading a cattle to slaughter" is taking on even more vivid thoughts.

Graphemes

What can the pronunciation of the word teach us about the relationship of its graphemes and its phonology?

This is a prime example of how the pronunciation of a word might lead a student to a complete misunderstanding of the word. If we think the /trʌk/ of truculent is related to a truck, then we will have missed the point of the word completely.

Some students might misspell the as

The suffix is another potential place where a student might misspell this word. The suffixes &amp;amp;amp;lt;-ant&amp;amp;amp;gt; and &amp;amp;amp;lt;-ent&amp;amp;amp;gt; are often homophonic because their vowels are reduced to schwa. Although the suffix &amp;amp;amp;lt;-ent&amp;amp;amp;gt; often forms adjectives, it is not a reliable rule of thumb, as &amp;amp;amp;lt;-ant&amp;amp;amp;gt; can as well in words like important and verdant.


Next Steps

What can we learn next about the English orthographic system?

What might be some common idioms you can begin studying?

Have you studied the suffixes &amp;amp;amp;lt;-ant&amp;amp;amp;gt; and &amp;amp;amp;lt;-ent&amp;amp;amp;gt;? Or their counterparts in &amp;amp;amp;lt;-ance&amp;amp;amp;gt; or &amp;amp;amp;lt;-ence&amp;amp;amp;gt;?

What is the difference between a consonant cluster and a digraph? And why would I avoid using the term "consonant blend?"


Stay curious,

Brad

P.S. A quick rule of thumb regarding the suffixes &amp;amp;amp;lt;-ant&amp;amp;amp;gt; and &amp;amp;amp;lt;-ent&amp;amp;amp;gt; is to look at their infinitive forms. If the infinitive form ends in &amp;amp;amp;lt;-are&amp;amp;amp;gt;, then &amp;amp;amp;lt;-ant&amp;amp;amp;gt; is more likely; if the infinitive form ends in &amp;amp;amp;lt;-ere&amp;amp;amp;gt;, then &amp;amp;amp;lt;-ent&amp;amp;amp;gt; is more likely. This generalization doesn't always hold however, as these forms were leveled when they moved into French, which is how we get resistant from sistere. Noun forms also ended up with forms &amp;amp;amp;lt;-ance&amp;amp;amp;gt; and &amp;amp;amp;lt;-ence&amp;amp;amp;gt;. No

One Step Now Education

113 Cherry St #92768, Seattle, WA 98104-2205
Unsubscribe · Preferences

background

Subscribe to Discover how spelling works in only five minutes a week.